Pseudomedicine

Pseudomedicine is a term for treatments that claim to be working concepts of medicine but have no objectively verifiable benefit or are incompatible with the current state of knowledge in the field of science based medicine (or evidence based medicine, EBM). Pseudomedical treatments present themselves often as established treatments, often using or misusing terms from scientific medicine and sciences. They are the pseudoscience of medicine.

Evidencebased medicine uses some treatments too, where effectiveness is reproducible, but where it is not known in detail, why or how they work. Such treatments are not counted as pseudomedicine.

The term pseudomedicine overlaps partially with the terms Alternative medicine and Complementary Medicine, which are used by supporters of pseudomedical treatments as well as its critics as a synonym for pseudomedicine. Pseudomedical practitioners on the other hand often refer to the science based medicine – derogatory – as orthodox medicine.

Typical characteristics

Pseudomedical treatments can often be identified by the following characteristics:

1. Providers refer to unusually extensive training and qualifications in many institutions ("with Ph.D. such-and-such")
2. Drug contents are not defined precisely, their composition is changed continuously
3. Claims that the "orthodox medicine" sees humans just as "chemical machines" or something like that
4. A "change of paradigm in medicine is necessary, imminent or has already happened
5. Claims the the method is based on modern science and refers to established concepts that are laypersons difficult to understand for laypersons like theory of relativity or (currently common) quantum mechanics (in terms of quantum mysticism )
6. Concepts borrowed from the natural sciences such as energy, wave, frequency resonance or field are used in a vague way, but usually as if everyone would know what is meant with, for example, "field"
7. Enumerates names of famous scientists like Planck, Bohr, Einstein and Heisenberg
8. Mentions names such as Galileo and Semmelweis, as examples for researchers whose findings have been accepted only very much later
9. Remote effects of drugs or healing powers are claimed and justified with an "holistic world view" ("everything is connected in the universe") or with quantum mechanics (" quantum entanglement ")
10. Simple, intuitive, if not naive theories on the alleged mechanism (often in addition to referring to complicated theories such as quantum physics) are given. Examples: cancer: Starve cancer with a diet, burn cancer with Hyperthermie, remove harmful vibrations by application of reverse polarity oscillations (Bioresonance)
11. No contraindications and no side effects
12. Treatments are applicable to many diseases (if not all) and effective in all stages of the disease
13. Diagnostic- and therapy devices can not only be used to treat diseases but are also recommended for e.g. consultants, dating services, building biologists and farmers
14. Measurements and concentrations are feigned to be larger or smaller by abuse of unit resolutions

See also:

• Ten indicators of quackery
• Rhetoric of the pseudo-doctors and marketers of dubious products
• Characteristics of ineffective technical products

Examples

A great number of pseudoscientific Treatments and diagnostic procedures is listed in various categories at Psiram:

Pseudomedical phytotherapy with protected species

Many remedies use ingredients of natural origin. Among those plants about 350 protected plant species are found. Examples are:

• Hoodia spp.
• Prunus africana (syn.Pygeum africanum). Commercial banned
• Saussurea costus (syn. S. lappa)
• Arnica
• Canadian turmeric
• Adonis

Trade with these plants or with preparations of them is only permitted unter special control of the organisation CITES.

Through intensive harvesting for international commercial use many plant species are ruthlessly exploited and thus threatened by extinction today. At the same time, proof of effectiveness is the often weak or nonexistent.

Pseudomedicine and animal protection

Asian black bears held captive for the extraction of bile

Some reagents, that are used in pseudomedical methods (especially of far eastern origin) come from the hunt for animals threatened by extinction or that are otherwise legally protected.

Used are for example tiger bone or rhino horn or even sea horse to increase the virility.. Poaching on these species because of the attributed effects of the reagent endangers many species in a pointless way. A further example is the massive catch of sharks or sea horses to win shark cartilage for "medical" purposes, which brought several species to the brink of extinction.

Ursodeoxycholic acid is a reagent still won in Traditional chinese medicine from the bile of living Asian black bears, which are implanted with a permanent cannula to "tap" the animals on a daily basis. It is an unimaginable cruelty to the animals, which are held in small cages on so called bear farms. The medically useful substance ursodeoxycholic acid for liver diseases can be created purely synthetic for a long time now. Nevertheless, many customers prefer the animal derived variant.

Versions of this article in other languages

• Français: Pseudo-médecine
• Deutsch: Pseudomedizin

Literature

• J. Brissonnet: Les pseudomédecines, coll. Zététique, Book-e-book.com, 2003 [1]
• Edzard Ernst: The Desktop Guide to Complementary and Alternative Medicine. An evidence-based approach. Mosby, Harcourt Publishers Limited 2001
• Colin Goldner: Alternative Diagnose- und Therapieverfahren: Eine kritische Bestandsaufnahme. Alibri 2008
• Martin Lambeck: Irrt die Physik? Über alternative Medizin und Esoterik, Beck Verlag 2003
• Simon Singh, Edzard Ernst: Trick or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts about Alternative Medicine. Random House 2008
• See also: Literature in article Alternative Medicine

Weblinks

• http://www.zeit.de/zeit-wissen/2006/02/Essay_Lambeck
• http://www.quackwatch.org/13Hx/MM/18.html
• http://www.amuseum.de/medizin/CibaZeitung/sep36.htm