Difference between revisions of "Law of similars"
(inserted link to german page) |
m |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | The | + | The Law of Similars or similarity principle ([[Samuel Hahnemann]]: ''similia similibus curentur'') is one of the two basic concepts of [[homoeopathy]]. According to this principle, every disease is said to be curable by substances causing similar symptoms when taken by a healthy patient. The Law of Similars is not only a rule of thumb in homoeopathy but is understood as a basic law of nature. |
| + | |||
| + | The Law of Similars was not invented by Hahnemann who rediscovered it and made it popular. It has been handed down from Hippokrates: "By similar things a disease is produced and through the application of the like is cured." | ||
| + | <ref>http://www.uni-duesseldorf.de/kojda-pharmalehrbuch/fortbildungkoeln/Verspohl_HomoeopathieKoeln.pdf</ref> The sentence ''Contraria contrariis curantur'' is also attributed to Hippocrates and Galenus. Paracelsus said something similar: "similia similibus curantur". It has to be noted here that the indicative (curantur - cured) is different from the subjunctive mood used by Hahnemann (curentur - shall be cured). | ||
| + | Hahnemann distanced himself strictly from the [[Doctrine of Signatures]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | In academic medicine it is applied in the broad sense for allergen immunotherapy and for vaccinations. In general, there is the problem that there is no scientific definition for the term "similar". Similarities are not an objective feature, but created by pattern recognition in the brain and depend on the oberserver's knowledge and abilities of observation. It depends furthermore on type and quality of the inspection.<ref>[https://blog.piratenpartei-nrw.de/logos/files/2011/11/Hom%C3%B6opathie%E2%80%93Betrachtung_aus_Sicht_der_Wissenschaft-PP-Version3.pdf Timm, H.: Homöopathie – Betrachtung aus Sicht der Wissenschaft S.8] on blog.piratenpartei-nrw.de 08.12.2011</ref> | ||
Taken serious scientifically, the principle is easily disproved. It does not take more than to come up with one disease which cannot be cured by similars. One such example is sufficient to falsify (disprove) a theory expressed so broadly. Even viewed as a mere rule of thumb, it may be expected to find a vast majority of diseases which will be cured by remedies causing similar symptoms. However, such a general proof of efficacy could not be provided. Therefore, the law of similars corresponds to magical thinking and has no relation to science. | Taken serious scientifically, the principle is easily disproved. It does not take more than to come up with one disease which cannot be cured by similars. One such example is sufficient to falsify (disprove) a theory expressed so broadly. Even viewed as a mere rule of thumb, it may be expected to find a vast majority of diseases which will be cured by remedies causing similar symptoms. However, such a general proof of efficacy could not be provided. Therefore, the law of similars corresponds to magical thinking and has no relation to science. | ||
| − | [[Samuel Hahnemann]], the founder of homoeopathy, referred to his successful chinchona test which had inspired the | + | [[Samuel Hahnemann]], the founder of homoeopathy, referred to his successful chinchona test which had inspired the Law of Similars. This experiment, however, could not be replicated, and is to be seen as one of the errors of homoeopathic doctrine. The Law of Similars already had been discussed prior to Hahnemann, but was made popular first through homoeopathy. |
| − | |||
| − | |||
{{OtherLang|ge=Simile-Prinzip|en=law of similars}} | {{OtherLang|ge=Simile-Prinzip|en=law of similars}} | ||
| + | ==References== | ||
| + | <references /> | ||
[[category:Homoeopathy]] | [[category:Homoeopathy]] | ||
Latest revision as of 04:28, 17 December 2014
The Law of Similars or similarity principle (Samuel Hahnemann: similia similibus curentur) is one of the two basic concepts of homoeopathy. According to this principle, every disease is said to be curable by substances causing similar symptoms when taken by a healthy patient. The Law of Similars is not only a rule of thumb in homoeopathy but is understood as a basic law of nature.
The Law of Similars was not invented by Hahnemann who rediscovered it and made it popular. It has been handed down from Hippokrates: "By similar things a disease is produced and through the application of the like is cured." [1] The sentence Contraria contrariis curantur is also attributed to Hippocrates and Galenus. Paracelsus said something similar: "similia similibus curantur". It has to be noted here that the indicative (curantur - cured) is different from the subjunctive mood used by Hahnemann (curentur - shall be cured). Hahnemann distanced himself strictly from the Doctrine of Signatures.
In academic medicine it is applied in the broad sense for allergen immunotherapy and for vaccinations. In general, there is the problem that there is no scientific definition for the term "similar". Similarities are not an objective feature, but created by pattern recognition in the brain and depend on the oberserver's knowledge and abilities of observation. It depends furthermore on type and quality of the inspection.[2]
Taken serious scientifically, the principle is easily disproved. It does not take more than to come up with one disease which cannot be cured by similars. One such example is sufficient to falsify (disprove) a theory expressed so broadly. Even viewed as a mere rule of thumb, it may be expected to find a vast majority of diseases which will be cured by remedies causing similar symptoms. However, such a general proof of efficacy could not be provided. Therefore, the law of similars corresponds to magical thinking and has no relation to science.
Samuel Hahnemann, the founder of homoeopathy, referred to his successful chinchona test which had inspired the Law of Similars. This experiment, however, could not be replicated, and is to be seen as one of the errors of homoeopathic doctrine. The Law of Similars already had been discussed prior to Hahnemann, but was made popular first through homoeopathy.
Versions of this article in other languages
- Deutsch: Simile-Prinzip
References
- ↑ http://www.uni-duesseldorf.de/kojda-pharmalehrbuch/fortbildungkoeln/Verspohl_HomoeopathieKoeln.pdf
- ↑ Timm, H.: Homöopathie – Betrachtung aus Sicht der Wissenschaft S.8 on blog.piratenpartei-nrw.de 08.12.2011